BTCBTC$64,979+0.92%|
ETHETH$1,823.26+0.29%|
USDTUSDT$0.99932+0.00%|
BNBBNB$592.3300+0.53%|
USDCUSDC$0.99965+0.00%|
XRPXRP$0.97655+2.19%|
SOLSOL$73.9100+3.84%|
TRXTRX$0.30644+0.53%|
FIGR_HELOCFIGR_HELOC$1.0390-1.67%|
HYPEHYPE$69.9400+5.16%|
ZECZEC$956.5400+9.73%|
XMRXMR$510.5100+1.76%|
DOGEDOGE$0.05953+1.35%|
LEOLEO$9.2900+0.96%|
USDSUSDS$0.99992+0.00%|
WBTWBT$62.7600+0.52%|
LINKLINK$9.3200+1.62%|
ADAADA$0.15541+1.85%|
XLMXLM$0.14036+2.12%|
USDEUSDE$0.99944+0.02%|
DAIDAI$1.0000+0.01%|
BCHBCH$212.6200+2.37%|
NEARNEAR$3.2600+2.80%|
RAINRAIN$0.00553383-21.31%|
LTCLTC$45.0300+1.25%|
UNIUNI$5.4400+5.93%|
CCCC$0.08210-1.12%|
AVAXAVAX$7.2700+1.80%|
XAUTXAUT$3,846.22-0.10%|
SUISUI$0.73911+2.75%|
BTCBTC$64,979+0.92%|
ETHETH$1,823.26+0.29%|
USDTUSDT$0.99932+0.00%|
BNBBNB$592.3300+0.53%|
USDCUSDC$0.99965+0.00%|
XRPXRP$0.97655+2.19%|
SOLSOL$73.9100+3.84%|
TRXTRX$0.30644+0.53%|
FIGR_HELOCFIGR_HELOC$1.0390-1.67%|
HYPEHYPE$69.9400+5.16%|
ZECZEC$956.5400+9.73%|
XMRXMR$510.5100+1.76%|
DOGEDOGE$0.05953+1.35%|
LEOLEO$9.2900+0.96%|
USDSUSDS$0.99992+0.00%|
WBTWBT$62.7600+0.52%|
LINKLINK$9.3200+1.62%|
ADAADA$0.15541+1.85%|
XLMXLM$0.14036+2.12%|
USDEUSDE$0.99944+0.02%|
DAIDAI$1.0000+0.01%|
BCHBCH$212.6200+2.37%|
NEARNEAR$3.2600+2.80%|
RAINRAIN$0.00553383-21.31%|
LTCLTC$45.0300+1.25%|
UNIUNI$5.4400+5.93%|
CCCC$0.08210-1.12%|
AVAXAVAX$7.2700+1.80%|
XAUTXAUT$3,846.22-0.10%|
SUISUI$0.73911+2.75%|
News/Regulation

Bitfinex: The Tokenized Stocks Fight Isn't About Vetoes

Bitfinex platform displaying tokenized U.S. stocks alongside blockchain links, market charts and regulatory symbols representing the debate over access and market rules.

Summary :

  • Bitfinex says the tokenized stocks fight is about what tokens represent, not veto rights.

  • Jesse Knutson: "what exactly does the token represent and who can access it?"

  • Robinhood's CEO compares stock tokens to unsponsored depositary receipts.

  • Coinbase's rival model holds real shares 1:1 via an ADGM trust structure.

  • Unsponsored private-equity tokens carry the worst information asymmetry.

The tokenized stocks fight has moved past the question everyone was shouting about, and Bitfinex is the one reframing it. As the AMC-Robinhood dispute escalated, the debate was framed as issuer consent, whether companies can veto tokenized versions of their shares, after AMC CEO Adam Aron rejected an unapproved AMC-linked token and threatened SEC review, and as the exchange refused to stand down. Jesse Knutson, head of operations at Bitfinex Securities, argues that framing misses the point: "The debate shouldn't really be 'does the issuer get a veto?' It should be: what exactly does the token represent and who can access it?"

The distinction is not academic. Robinhood's tokens are debt instruments issued by its Jersey SPV, giving holders economic exposure with no voting rights or shareholder status, a structure CEO Vlad Tenev defends by comparing them to unsponsored depositary receipts, which tradFi markets have long permitted without issuer blessing.

The Three Models of Tokenized Stocks

Strip the rhetoric and the market has settled into three distinct products wearing the same name. First, synthetic debt wrappers, Robinhood's model: the token is a claim on an SPV, not on the company, and scales without issuer consent because the company never participates, the same structure OpenAI disavowed in July 2025 when Robinhood listed Europe-only tokens tied to OpenAI and SpaceX with no partnership, supplying exposure through a special purpose vehicle. Second, beneficial-interest trust models, Coinbase's approach after it joined the tokenized stock market via Base: underlying shares held 1:1 in trust custody by SEC-registered broker Alpaca, tokens described in the prospectus as a "proportional beneficial interest in a pool of deposited property." Third, permissioned issuer-backed models, what Bitfinex Securities itself is building toward, where the issuer participates and the token's rights mirror actual securities. Knutson's key point is that these are different assets with different risk profiles: "The market is likely to have both models, but investors need to understand which one they're buying." An SPV debt token carries issuer credit risk over true equity claims; a trust token carries custody and wrapper risk; and pricing all three off the same ticker conceals the differences until a stress event makes them visible.

Where the Real Danger Sits: Private Markets

The sharpest edge of Knutson's argument is about the frontier, unsponsored tokens of private companies, where he warns the asymmetry is worst: "Unsponsored private equity is a lot more complicated due to potential information asymmetry... token investors trade only on headlines." Public equity tokenized without consent at least has public filings behind its price; a private-company token priced on rumors and press coverage is a different instrument wearing the same interface, with insiders holding audited financials and token buyers holding vibes. His compliance point is equally practical: "Listed companies obviously don't want tokenized versions of their stocks ending up in sanctioned or prohibited jurisdictions," which is precisely what issuer-consent mechanisms exist to police, and what blanket no-veto positions struggle to answer, a live question as the SEC weighs tokenized equities policy.

The Honest Middle

The fair reading of the whole fight: both camps are right about different things. The no-veto camp is right that issuers have never controlled secondary wrappers on their shares, depositary receipts, CFDs, and options all trade the reference asset without consent, and that a veto would hand every company a negotiation lever over retail access. The consent camp is right that a 24/7, globally distributed instrument is categorically different from a regulated-venue derivative, and that the exchange-traded wrappers of the past never let retail in sanctioned jurisdictions hold the exposure directly. The market will likely resolve this with disclosure rather than ideology, labeled instruments, published wrapper structures, and redemption terms, which is exactly the standard Knutson is proposing the industry adopt.

Watch whether exchanges start publishing token classification labels voluntarily, and whether the SEC's tokenized equities workstream mandates disclosure of wrapper structure. The veto question was the season's argument. What a token actually is will be the sector's permanent one.

#Bitfinex#Tokenized Stocks#Robinhood#Coinbase#Jesse Knutson#RWA
Meher Bhaduri

Author

Meher Bhaduri

Regulatory Affairs Writer

Meher Bhaduri has covered crypto regulation and policy for 9 months, tracking legislative developments and compliance changes across major jurisdictions. She focuses on making regulatory shifts understandable for everyday crypto users and businesses.

Suggest a correction or update

Spotted something missing, outdated or incorrect on this page? Tell us what needs updating and share an official source or supporting link so our team can verify it.

More Regulation News

Share:

Bitnxt uses cookies to run the site, understand how it is used, and measure ads. You can accept or decline below, and change your choice any time in our Privacy Policy.