BTCBTC$63,725-1.75%|
ETHETH$1,783.66-2.27%|
USDTUSDT$0.99922-0.01%|
BNBBNB$585.9600-0.71%|
USDCUSDC$0.99960+0.00%|
XRPXRP$0.95764-0.20%|
SOLSOL$72.2800+1.36%|
TRXTRX$0.30680+0.12%|
FIGR_HELOCFIGR_HELOC$1.0420-0.98%|
HYPEHYPE$68.4400+2.29%|
ZECZEC$929.8000+4.73%|
XMRXMR$504.2400+1.61%|
DOGEDOGE$0.05854-1.38%|
LEOLEO$9.2900+1.32%|
USDSUSDS$1.0000+0.09%|
WBTWBT$61.5200-1.95%|
LINKLINK$9.1200-0.52%|
ADAADA$0.15202-0.51%|
XLMXLM$0.13761+0.29%|
USDEUSDE$0.99938-0.00%|
DAIDAI$1.0000+0.02%|
BCHBCH$207.4100-0.14%|
NEARNEAR$3.1800+0.68%|
LTCLTC$44.2500-0.96%|
UNIUNI$5.2600+2.94%|
CCCC$0.07951-3.37%|
RAINRAIN$0.00443494-33.66%|
AVAXAVAX$7.0900-1.16%|
XAUTXAUT$3,851.61+0.01%|
GRAMGRAM$1.0650+1.12%|
BTCBTC$63,725-1.75%|
ETHETH$1,783.66-2.27%|
USDTUSDT$0.99922-0.01%|
BNBBNB$585.9600-0.71%|
USDCUSDC$0.99960+0.00%|
XRPXRP$0.95764-0.20%|
SOLSOL$72.2800+1.36%|
TRXTRX$0.30680+0.12%|
FIGR_HELOCFIGR_HELOC$1.0420-0.98%|
HYPEHYPE$68.4400+2.29%|
ZECZEC$929.8000+4.73%|
XMRXMR$504.2400+1.61%|
DOGEDOGE$0.05854-1.38%|
LEOLEO$9.2900+1.32%|
USDSUSDS$1.0000+0.09%|
WBTWBT$61.5200-1.95%|
LINKLINK$9.1200-0.52%|
ADAADA$0.15202-0.51%|
XLMXLM$0.13761+0.29%|
USDEUSDE$0.99938-0.00%|
DAIDAI$1.0000+0.02%|
BCHBCH$207.4100-0.14%|
NEARNEAR$3.1800+0.68%|
LTCLTC$44.2500-0.96%|
UNIUNI$5.2600+2.94%|
CCCC$0.07951-3.37%|
RAINRAIN$0.00443494-33.66%|
AVAXAVAX$7.0900-1.16%|
XAUTXAUT$3,851.61+0.01%|
GRAMGRAM$1.0650+1.12%|
News/Regulation

Underdog Sues Connecticut, Extending a Six-State Prediction Fight

Bitnxt TeamWritten by : Bitnxt Team
September 16, 20265 min read
US legal aur prediction market dispute ko dikhata concept image, jisme judge ka gavel, justice scale, highlighted US map, Bitcoin aur Ethereum coins, aur sports prediction dashboard wala laptop aur phone dikh rahe hain.

Summary :

  • Underdog sued Connecticut in federal court after the state ordered several prediction-market platforms to stop offering sports event contracts without gambling licenses.

  • The company argues that, as a federally regulated designated contract market, its trading activity falls under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction and should preempt state gambling laws.

  • Connecticut is the sixth state Underdog has sued over similar enforcement, following Ohio, Massachusetts, Wisconsin, New Mexico, and Washington.

  • Courts have reached different conclusions in related cases involving prediction markets, creating an ongoing legal dispute over whether sports event contracts are federally regulated derivatives or state-regulated gambling products.

  • The Connecticut case adds to a broader nationwide battle involving multiple platforms, state regulators, federal agencies, and a pending effort to bring the jurisdictional question before the U.S. Supreme Court.

Prediction market operator Underdog has sued Connecticut in federal court to block the state from treating its sports event contracts as illegal gambling, extending a preemption fight that now spans six states and may be heading to the Supreme Court. The complaint, filed Tuesday and seeking declaratory and injunctive relief, argues that Underdog operates a federally regulated designated contract market and that the Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC "exclusive jurisdiction" over trading conducted on DCMs, making Connecticut's enforcement "meritless." The trigger was last week's move by the Connecticut Department of Consumer Protection, which issued cease-and-desist orders to nine prediction market platforms, Underdog, Polymarket, Coinbase, Crypto.com and Robinhood among them, for offering sports event contracts without state gambling licenses.

"Our laws are clear: sports betting may only be offered by legal, licensed sportsbooks that adhere to our regulations and technical standards," DCP Commissioner Bryan Cafferelli said when the orders were announced.

The Six-State Legal War Over Sports Event Contracts

Underdog's strategy is now a template: earlier in September it sued Ohio, Massachusetts, Wisconsin, New Mexico and Washington over the same enforcement theory, and Connecticut makes six. The company's core argument is federal preemption, the CEA occupies the field for DCM-traded contracts, so state gambling law cannot reach them, and it is the same argument Kalshi and Novig have run, with mixed results that now define the battleground. A New York federal judge denied Kalshi's preliminary injunction in July, finding the company had not shown the CEA likely preempts New York's gambling laws at that stage. The Ninth Circuit ruled against Kalshi in Nevada on August 28, with Circuit Judge Ryan Nelson writing "The CFTC is not a national gambling regulator" and allowing Nevada's enforcement to continue, but the Third Circuit kept Kalshi's preliminary protection in place in New Jersey in April, finding a reasonable likelihood its sports contracts qualify as swaps under the CEA. That circuit split is why New Jersey petitioned the Supreme Court on September 2 to decide the question, the escalation we foreshadowed in the jurisdictional battles around Kalshi's market expansion, and by early September Casino.org counted 38 active prediction-market cases across 21 states with enforcement underway in 10 jurisdictions, plus a federal overlay: the CFTC and DOJ sued Connecticut, Illinois and Arizona in April, arguing state interference with federally registered prediction markets.

Why Underdog Is Fighting From a Weaker Position

The honest read of Underdog's odds, and its timing, cuts against the company. It is smaller than Kalshi and Polymarket, with combined platform volume of $50.59 billion in July across Kalshi, Polymarket and Polymarket US, Kalshi alone accounting for $37.7 billion, Underdog is a niche player whose sports contracts are its core product, and it is being acquired by UK-based IG Group for up to $1.3 billion, announced in July after a $70 million Series C valuing it at $1.23 billion in March 2025, meaning every adverse ruling lands on a live deal price. Its litigation position also inherits the Ninth Circuit's reasoning: if sports event contracts are "likely sports bets rather than swaps" at the preliminary stage, the preemption defense has already lost its strongest framing once, and the Third Circuit's contrary finding is what the Supreme Court will be asked to referee. The DCM status itself is the strongest card, the CFTC designated Underdog's market and federal registration is the entire preemption theory, and the prediction-market expansion that made these fights worth having, from sports-league talks with Polymarket and Kalshi to the European regulator warnings, is what turned state gaming commissions from indifferent to hostile: sports contracts have become the volume engine, and states protect their taxed sportsbooks.

What the Connecticut Case Adds to the National Fight

Connecticut is a useful sixth front because its posture is aggressive and layered: it sued Kalshi in August seeking an injunction against unlicensed sports contracts, having first ordered Kalshi, Robinhood and Crypto.com to stop in December 2025, and last week's nine-platform cease-and-desist shows a state regulator treating the entire category as licensable gambling at once, which gives the industry a single target for a category-defining ruling. The state's framing, licensed sportsbooks with technical standards versus CFTC-regulated exchanges, is the cleanest statement of the stakes either side has produced, and the case law now developing, New York denial, Ninth Circuit against, Third Circuit for, Supreme Court petition pending, means every new filing is both a defense and a bid to shape the record the justices will see. The industry's collective exposure is no longer theoretical: nine platforms in one state simultaneously, 38 cases in 21 states, and a federal regulator suing three of those same states, a constitutional turf war with a Goliath-versus-Goliath structure.

What to Watch

Watch the Supreme Court's response to New Jersey's petition, the event that would settle the circuit split; watch whether Underdog's acquirer IG Group publicly backs the litigation or renegotiates around its risk; and watch whether more states copy Connecticut's nine-platform sweep, since mass cease-and-desists force the industry to litigate nationally rather than exit state by state. Six states in, the prediction markets have stopped being a product category and become a jurisdictional question. The answer now sits with the courts.

#Underdog#Connecticut#Prediction Markets#CFTC#Kalshi#Preemption
Bitnxt Team

Author

Bitnxt Team

Crypto News Writer · Bitnxt

Covering the latest developments in cryptocurrency, blockchain technology, and digital asset markets.

Suggest a correction or update

Spotted something missing, outdated or incorrect on this page? Tell us what needs updating and share an official source or supporting link so our team can verify it.

More Regulation News

Share:

Bitnxt uses cookies to run the site, understand how it is used, and measure ads. You can accept or decline below, and change your choice any time in our Privacy Policy.