BTCBTC$63,767-1.36%|
ETHETH$1,777.95-2.50%|
USDTUSDT$0.99930-0.00%|
BNBBNB$584.4400-0.85%|
USDCUSDC$0.99962+0.00%|
XRPXRP$0.95697+0.09%|
SOLSOL$72.2000+1.61%|
TRXTRX$0.30738+0.41%|
FIGR_HELOCFIGR_HELOC$1.0300-3.16%|
HYPEHYPE$67.6500+1.35%|
ZECZEC$929.6300+4.80%|
XMRXMR$500.4800+0.41%|
DOGEDOGE$0.05822-1.74%|
LEOLEO$9.2900+0.89%|
USDSUSDS$0.99999+0.00%|
WBTWBT$61.5200-1.65%|
LINKLINK$9.0900-0.78%|
ADAADA$0.15124-0.81%|
XLMXLM$0.13709+0.23%|
USDEUSDE$0.99937+0.00%|
DAIDAI$1.0000+0.03%|
BCHBCH$206.8800+0.27%|
NEARNEAR$3.1500-0.65%|
LTCLTC$44.2700-0.70%|
RAINRAIN$0.00465536-36.42%|
UNIUNI$5.2700+3.07%|
CCCC$0.07981-2.88%|
AVAXAVAX$7.0500-1.18%|
XAUTXAUT$3,851.66+0.26%|
GRAMGRAM$1.0620+0.94%|
BTCBTC$63,767-1.36%|
ETHETH$1,777.95-2.50%|
USDTUSDT$0.99930-0.00%|
BNBBNB$584.4400-0.85%|
USDCUSDC$0.99962+0.00%|
XRPXRP$0.95697+0.09%|
SOLSOL$72.2000+1.61%|
TRXTRX$0.30738+0.41%|
FIGR_HELOCFIGR_HELOC$1.0300-3.16%|
HYPEHYPE$67.6500+1.35%|
ZECZEC$929.6300+4.80%|
XMRXMR$500.4800+0.41%|
DOGEDOGE$0.05822-1.74%|
LEOLEO$9.2900+0.89%|
USDSUSDS$0.99999+0.00%|
WBTWBT$61.5200-1.65%|
LINKLINK$9.0900-0.78%|
ADAADA$0.15124-0.81%|
XLMXLM$0.13709+0.23%|
USDEUSDE$0.99937+0.00%|
DAIDAI$1.0000+0.03%|
BCHBCH$206.8800+0.27%|
NEARNEAR$3.1500-0.65%|
LTCLTC$44.2700-0.70%|
RAINRAIN$0.00465536-36.42%|
UNIUNI$5.2700+3.07%|
CCCC$0.07981-2.88%|
AVAXAVAX$7.0500-1.18%|
XAUTXAUT$3,851.66+0.26%|
GRAMGRAM$1.0620+0.94%|
News/Regulation

Susquehanna's $100 Million Freeze Died on a 49-to-1 Ratio

Susquehanna's $100 Million Freeze Died on a 49-to-1 Ratio

Summary:

  • Judge Arun Subramanian denied Susquehanna's bid to freeze nearly $100 million tied to traders accused of trading on nonpublic information before China's May 22 crackdown announcement.

  • The court found no imminent risk of asset dissipation and no likelihood of success on the Section 20A insider trading claim.

  • Defendant Zhengfei Li showed a roughly 49-to-1 put-to-call ratio on May 21 — public signals that undercut the nonpublic-information theory.

  • Susquehanna sued 100 unnamed defendants in June and narrowed its injunction request to 40; Citadel Securities joined as an intervenor.

  • Watch whether the case survives into discovery — the judge faulted the joiner of dozens of unrelated traders into one broad action.

Susquehanna wanted a freeze on nearly $100 million it says traders stole from the options market using inside knowledge of China's May 22 crackdown on cross-border trading platforms. Judge Arun Subramanian said no. In a September 14 opinion from the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, the court denied both the preliminary injunction and the alternative attachment order, finding the market maker had shown neither a risk that the defendants would spirit the money away nor a likelihood of winning its insider trading claims. For a case built on the premise that dozens of unrelated traders all had the same secret, the ruling is a serious structural blow.

The stakes deserve a beat of setup. Susquehanna Securities and Susquehanna Investment Group filed suit on June 29 against 100 unnamed defendants, alleging violations of Section 20A of the Securities Exchange Act and unjust enrichment, later narrowing the injunction request to 40 traders. Citadel Securities joined as an intervenor. The theory: defendants loaded up on short-dated put options that expired on or just after May 22 — the day Chinese regulators targeted cross-border brokerage activity by firms including Tiger Brokers, Futu and Longbridge — and profited when the news hit. The company argued there was no plausible explanation for that pattern other than material nonpublic information. The court's answer explains why plausible patterns are not proof.

Why the Susquehanna Insider Trading Case Stalled

The denial rests on two familiar pillars of preliminary-injunction law, and Susquehanna failed both. On irreparable harm, the company leaned on the suspiciousness of the trading itself: people who trade dirty might flee with the money. The judge rejected that logic as circular — accepting it would make asset freezes automatic in essentially every insider trading case. For domestic defendants who had not appeared in the case, the court noted some had not even been served yet, and absence is not evidence of hiding. For foreign defendants, the difficulty of enforcing a U.S. judgment overseas was not, by itself, irreparable harm. The closest call was John Doe 3, who Susquehanna said had moved more than $10 million out of an account before a freeze could take effect — but the court found no supporting evidence, and moving money between accounts is what active traders do; it does not prove an intent to defeat a judgment.

On the merits, Section 20A requires a fiduciary or trusted party who misused material nonpublic information or tipped it for a benefit. Susquehanna's trading charts showed a striking pattern of risky puts expiring around the announcement. But the defendants supplied something the charts could not absorb: public evidence of suspicion in the market itself. Zhengfei Li's records showed two equally sized positions, half expiring before May 22 and half after — consistent, he argued, with repeated speculation on market signals rather than precise knowledge of a date. He submitted data showing a put-to-call ratio of roughly 49 to 1 on May 21, the day he entered his positions, driven by publicly visible activity and investor chatter. Another defendant described buying puts for similar reasons and supplied her own messages reacting when the crackdown news broke. Information available publicly is, by definition, not nonpublic information. The judge allowed that some defendants' records looked more suspicious than Li's — but Susquehanna had bundled them all into one action with broad arguments instead of individualized proof, never identifying the tipper, the fiduciary duty or the personal benefit that the statute requires.

What the Ruling Means for the Next Case

The decision is a template for how crowded, aggregate insider-trading theories die early. Subramanian's central observation was evidentiary: a hundred investors who do not know each other can share a trade without sharing a source — unusual market activity is itself a public signal that draws speculators, which is precisely the innocent explanation the put-to-call ratio supported. The proportion problem compounded it: Susquehanna originally accused 100 defendants of receiving insider information, then stopped seeking injunctions against more than half of them, a retreat the court pointedly noticed. Market makers have real reasons to pursue these cases — they are often the counterparty absorbing the other side of informed flow, a vulnerability that has made trading venues the recurring scene of crypto's insider trading cases — but this ruling prices the cost of bringing breadth instead of depth.

The China context frames why the trading was so one-directional in the first place. The May 22 action extended a clampdown that began with February restrictions on offshore platforms serving mainland users, and days after the announcement China's Supreme People's Court said it would study rules for virtual currency disputes and cross-border financial cases. Enforcement abroad has kept pace: a Shanghai court in July sentenced five people over an illegal foreign-exchange network that used cryptocurrency to move more than $29.4 million out of the country. Traders watching Chinese regulatory action build had every opportunity to place bearish bets without a tip — which is exactly what several of them told the court.

What Comes Next

The freeze is dead, not the case. Susquehanna can still pursue its claims through discovery, where the tables turn in its favor: defendants can be compelled to explain their trading, and any actual coordination or tipper relationship would surface in records the injunction stage never reached. But the burden is now heavier — the court has put its assessment of the evidence on the record, and similar successful crypto-related prosecutions have succeeded on traced, individual conduct, not aggregate inference. The practical lesson for market participants is the mirror image of the lesson for plaintiffs: unusual options flow ahead of regulatory news is a fact pattern courts will scrutinize, but in an era when regulatory crackdowns are announced, leaked, discussed and predicted publicly, being early is not being inside. Susquehanna has to find the person who actually knew, not just the people who were right.

#Susquehanna#Citadel Securities#insider trading#SDNY#China#options trading#Section 20A
Pankajj Purohit

Author

Pankajj Purohit

Exchange & Industry News Writer

Pankajj Purohit has covered exchange news and industry developments for 3 months, reporting on listings, platform updates, and company announcements across the crypto space. He focuses on delivering timely, accurate industry coverage for Bitnxt.

Suggest a correction or update

Spotted something missing, outdated or incorrect on this page? Tell us what needs updating and share an official source or supporting link so our team can verify it.

More Regulation News

Share:

Bitnxt uses cookies to run the site, understand how it is used, and measure ads. You can accept or decline below, and change your choice any time in our Privacy Policy.