BTCBTC$65,579-4.69%|
ETHETH$1,837.04-4.95%|
USDTUSDT$0.99933+0.01%|
BNBBNB$597.4300-5.66%|
USDCUSDC$0.99963+0.01%|
XRPXRP$0.96938-4.91%|
SOLSOL$73.7200-7.77%|
TRXTRX$0.30967-1.04%|
FIGR_HELOCFIGR_HELOC$1.0460+4.43%|
HYPEHYPE$67.6100-7.46%|
ZECZEC$882.4300-6.87%|
XMRXMR$515.7600-3.15%|
DOGEDOGE$0.06098-6.44%|
USDSUSDS$0.99970-0.02%|
LEOLEO$9.2600-0.02%|
WBTWBT$63.8800-4.20%|
LINKLINK$9.2600-6.70%|
ADAADA$0.15690-8.50%|
XLMXLM$0.13953-5.75%|
USDEUSDE$0.99930+0.01%|
DAIDAI$0.99989+0.02%|
BCHBCH$211.7100-5.73%|
NEARNEAR$3.2100-8.43%|
LTCLTC$46.0100-6.61%|
AVAXAVAX$7.6600-8.39%|
CCCC$0.08229-5.77%|
UNIUNI$5.1100-12.23%|
USD1USD1$0.99811-0.02%|
XAUTXAUT$3,831.47-0.81%|
SUISUI$0.74055-8.53%|
BTCBTC$65,579-4.69%|
ETHETH$1,837.04-4.95%|
USDTUSDT$0.99933+0.01%|
BNBBNB$597.4300-5.66%|
USDCUSDC$0.99963+0.01%|
XRPXRP$0.96938-4.91%|
SOLSOL$73.7200-7.77%|
TRXTRX$0.30967-1.04%|
FIGR_HELOCFIGR_HELOC$1.0460+4.43%|
HYPEHYPE$67.6100-7.46%|
ZECZEC$882.4300-6.87%|
XMRXMR$515.7600-3.15%|
DOGEDOGE$0.06098-6.44%|
USDSUSDS$0.99970-0.02%|
LEOLEO$9.2600-0.02%|
WBTWBT$63.8800-4.20%|
LINKLINK$9.2600-6.70%|
ADAADA$0.15690-8.50%|
XLMXLM$0.13953-5.75%|
USDEUSDE$0.99930+0.01%|
DAIDAI$0.99989+0.02%|
BCHBCH$211.7100-5.73%|
NEARNEAR$3.2100-8.43%|
LTCLTC$46.0100-6.61%|
AVAXAVAX$7.6600-8.39%|
CCCC$0.08229-5.77%|
UNIUNI$5.1100-12.23%|
USD1USD1$0.99811-0.02%|
XAUTXAUT$3,831.47-0.81%|
SUISUI$0.74055-8.53%|
News/Regulation

Banks and 17 State AGs Hit CLARITY Act Before Vote

U.S. banks and state attorneys general challenging the CLARITY Act ahead of a congressional vote, with the Capitol, legal documents and crypto assets in view.

Summary :

  • Eight banking associations and 17 state attorneys general oppose the CLARITY Act.

  • The letters landed Sept. 14, one day before the 60-vote cloture test.

  • Banks want strict bans on stablecoin rewards; AGs fear SEC preemption.

  • The AG coalition cited $11.4B in 2025 crypto fraud losses, up 22% YoY.

  • Both coalitions reject the bill's proposed compromises outright.

The CLARITY Act faces its Senate test today with two powerful constituencies publicly against it, and the timing of their opposition, September 14, the day before the 60-vote cloture motion, was the message. Eight banking associations, including the American Bankers Association's coalition, wrote to Senate leaders John Thune and Chuck Schumer demanding changes to Section 10404's payment stablecoin rewards provisions, arguing that stablecoin rewards structured like deposit interest risk draining retail bank deposits and would "hinder the ability of depository institutions to extend credit to their customers." Their letter was blunt about first principles: "Deposits are the foundation of the banking system." Hours later, a bipartisan group of 17 state attorneys general led by New York's Letitia James, joined by California, Illinois, Arizona, Kansas, Ohio, and Wisconsin among others, sent their own letter to Banking Chair Tim Scott and Ranking Member Elizabeth Warren urging rejection of the bill entirely: "As written, the Clarity Act would embolden scammers and potentially strip attorneys general of our authority to protect our states' investors and their wallets."

Two different objections, one shared calculation: both coalitions believe the current draft's concessions do not protect them, and both decided a pre-vote letter maximizes pressure.

What the Banking Coalition Wants Changed

The banks' letter is surgical, aimed at the stablecoin rewards section rather than the bill's market-structure core. The associations demand the removal of "solely" from subsection (c)(1)(A) to close balance-reward loopholes, revised phrasing distinguishing a "payment stablecoin balance" from an "interest-bearing bank deposit," a "substantially similar" economic-effect test for rewards programs, and deletion of Section 10404(3)(B), which permits rewards based on balance size, holding period, or platform tenure. Most telling, they reject the compromise already in the draft, the 18-month Treasury circuit breaker that lets regulators restrict rewards during community-bank deposit stress, demanding strict statutory bans instead. That is the deposit-flight war escalating from theory to legislative text, the same battle we covered as the stablecoin yield clash between banks and crypto, now aimed at the exact provision that was supposed to buy peace. The banks are effectively conceding the market-structure framework while fighting to ban the yield feature that makes stablecoins competitive with checking accounts, a narrower war than last year's, which is itself a signal of how much ground the industry has already won.

The States' Preemption Fight

The attorneys general's objection is structural rather than textual. Their letter warns that the bill's authority to "preempt state registration authorities" gives the SEC broad discretion to override state securities registration, curtailing local enforcement against crypto fraud, and it arrives armed with data: FBI figures showing 2025 complaints involved $11.4 billion in crypto losses, up 22% year over year. Notably, the AGs concede the Sunday revisions gave them enforcement power over the new public-official conflict-of-interest rules, the ethics provisions added amid scrutiny of the president's World Liberty Financial and TRUMP memecoin holdings, but say that concession does nothing about securities preemption. "Together with my attorney general colleagues, I urge Congress not to pass the Clarity Act," James wrote. The irony worth naming: the bill was already struggling to find seven Democratic votes, as we tracked when prediction markets priced passage near one in ten before the final text lift, and the ethics concessions in that text were designed to win over exactly the moderates these letters now target, a dynamic visible since the ethics language first entered the negotiations.

Reading the Opposition Honestly

The skeptical read cuts both ways. For the banks, a lobbying letter the day before a vote is often a negotiation, a way to improve fallback language if cloture succeeds, and their willingness to engage text suggests they expect some version of this bill to pass eventually. For the AGs, the position is harder to reconcile with legislative reality: rejecting the entire bill preserves state power but also preserves the status quo the industry calls chaos, and the fraud losses they cite, $11.4 billion and climbing, are growing fastest precisely under today's uncertain jurisdictional split, the same void the missed Genius Act deadlines left open. What both letters demonstrate is that crypto's regulatory fight has fully traditional combatants now, deposit franchises and state blue-sky laws, each defending prerogatives older than Bitcoin.

Watch today's vote count for two specific signals: whether the seven targeted Democrats cite preemption or stablecoin yields in explanations, and whether the banking coalition's narrower demands resurface as a post-cloture amendment. The opposition does not decide the vote. It decides what the vote is about.

#CLARITY Act#Letitia James#American Bankers Association#Stablecoins#SEC#State Regulators
Meher Bhaduri

Author

Meher Bhaduri

Regulatory Affairs Writer

Meher Bhaduri has covered crypto regulation and policy for 9 months, tracking legislative developments and compliance changes across major jurisdictions. She focuses on making regulatory shifts understandable for everyday crypto users and businesses.

More Regulation News

Share:

Bitnxt uses cookies to run the site, understand how it is used, and measure ads. You can accept or decline below, and change your choice any time in our Privacy Policy.