A senior BaFin official has warned that centralizing EU crypto oversight could saddle firms with extra burdens while stripping MiCA of the flexibility that made it workable. Stephan Mögelin of Germany's Federal Financial Supervisory Authority, speaking on a panel at the European Blockchain Convention, argued that moving authorization and supervision from national regulators to a centralized EU body would not simply transfer responsibility, it would create a second round of work for firms that already completed national procedures. The intervention lands as Brussels reviews its MiCA framework, with the consultation extended to Sept. 30, and as register data shows banks surging into the EU crypto market through national authorization routes. Whether to keep that system is now an open question.
The MiCA oversight warning from inside BaFin
Mögelin's argument draws on precedent. "What we've seen, for example, in the application of EMIR, is that with a centralised supervisor, one might assume the application and understanding of specific provisions also becomes somewhat centralised," he said. Centralized oversight, in his account, leaves crypto-asset service providers with less flexibility when regulators apply individual provisions, because the interpreting authority is farther from the market it regulates. National regulators hold knowledge of local markets and business models that a central body would still depend on, which means centralization can degrade responsiveness without eliminating the dependence. His recommendation was pointedly neutral: market participants and clients should decide what they consider beneficial, because shifting responsibility to a centralized entity might add burdens regardless of the outcome.
The timing matters. Under MiCA, a provider authorized by a national regulator passports across the European Economic Area, a structure Ripple used in July when it secured authorization from Luxembourg's CSSF to offer regulated crypto payment services across 30 EEA countries. Mögelin's remarks highlight the trade-off inside that bargain: one authorization covers the region, but the applicant's experience still depends on how its home regulator reads the rules. Firms that just finished the process would bear transition costs again if the locus of authority moves, the kind of friction that the Binance licensing saga already made visible from the other direction.
The private-law hole in Europe's crypto rulebook
Mögelin identified a second gap that MiCA was never designed to fill. "From a supervisory and risk-management perspective, what we've seen so far is that MiCA and other European frameworks provide only a regulatory framework for financial services. What's still missing in most member states is a private law framework for specific crypto assets." Private law governs who legally owns a token, how transfers work, what contractual claims exist and how assets are treated when an intermediary fails. A financial-services license can regulate an exchange's conduct without answering whether the customer or the custodian owns the coin in insolvency. Without common treatment, the same token can fall under different ownership and insolvency rules depending on which member state hears the dispute, which is fragmentation wearing a uniform's clothes. The consultation is weighing whether a European-level private-law framework could close the hole, a question the UK is addressing in parallel through its digital asset strategy amendment backed by the House of Lords in September.
E-money tokens as the settlement leg
The most forward-looking part of the panel concerned e-money tokens, the MiCA category for crypto assets that maintain value by referencing one official currency. Mögelin said the convergence of crypto service providers and conventional financial institutions has increased interest in using e-money tokens inside traditional market infrastructure, specifically as the cash side of tokenized securities transactions. Tokenized trades need both legs to settle, and when the asset moves onchain while the payment waits for a bank transfer, parties face delays and completion risk. Regulators are now discussing whether e-money token services could extend to credit and lending, which could increase efficiency for firms operating across crypto assets and tokenized instruments.
The parallel with the US is instructive: a tokenized stock falls under securities rules there, while the stablecoin settling the trade raises separate reserve, redemption and banking questions. Europe is debating the same division of labor, but inside one framework and with an unresolved private-law layer. Mögelin did not call for removing national authorities from the system; he said even a centralized supervisor could benefit from member-state expertise. Watch the Sept. 30 consultation deadline and the next ESMA register updates together: if Brussels moves toward central oversight while the register keeps filling through national routes, Europe will be running two supervision models at once, and the burden Mögelin warned about will land on whichever firms are stuck between them.













































